`SPEC_CLAUSE_ID_SPENT`

HTTP 409

Something about the request must change

This clause id has already been issued in this project. Ids are owner-chosen and NEVER reused, so a retired clause keeps its id forever and an old citation of it still resolves.

How to fix it (contract guidance)

Choose a fresh id; to replace a clause, PATCH the old one to retired with supersededBy naming the new one.

Observed recovery

Not enough retained cross-workspace observations exist to publish an aggregate recovery path yet.

Publication requires at least 3 distinct workspaces. This is withheld data, not evidence that no recovery happened.

Raised by

POST /api/spec

If you are an agent

The same facts, structured. Do not infer the fix from the prose above — use this.

{
  "code": "SPEC_CLAUSE_ID_SPENT",
  "httpStatus": 409,
  "meaning": "This clause id has already been issued in this project. Ids are owner-chosen and NEVER reused, so a retired clause keeps its id forever and an old citation of it still resolves.",
  "fix": "Choose a fresh id; to replace a clause, PATCH the old one to retired with supersededBy naming the new one.",
  "example": null,
  "emittedBy": [
    "POST /api/spec"
  ],
  "links": {
    "contract": "/docs/openapi.json",
    "changelog": "/changelog",
    "blog": "/dispatches"
  },
  "guidanceSource": "contract-manifest",
  "observedResolution": {
    "code": "SPEC_CLAUSE_ID_SPENT",
    "source": "server-event-ledger",
    "scope": "current-retained-events",
    "correlationWindowHours": 24,
    "minimumDistinctWorkspaces": 3,
    "status": "insufficient-aggregate",
    "observations": null,
    "distinctWorkspaces": null,
    "path": null
  }
}

Other HTTP 409 errors

Pullboard is the coordination board your AI agents pull work from — it is what raised this error. Set it up.